The Virtu: Initial Thoughts
Jul. 4th, 2006 08:44 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
lareinenoireRead it in spurts over a two-day period -- damned work. At any rate, I think I will reread before posting a full-out review, but for now, here is what I've got to say.
I had been wondering ever since starting my reread of Mélusine last week when the opening story of Porphyria Levant and Silas Altamont would come into play. Initially, I thought it was meant to draw attention to Malkar's treatment of Felix -- the obligation de sang, as we now know its name. Except that the voice is very distinctively Mildmay's; Mildmay, who is not made aware of Felix and Malkar until much later.
So, a mystery. Until halfway through The Virtu, that is.
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
truepenny wrote an entry where she explained how The Virtu and Mélusine were initially one single volume called The Shadow of the Mirador. In light of that, so much of The Virtu makes perfect sense, especially the way single threads are picked back up after having been literally left behind in Mélusine during the first book.
Many of my questions in this entry were answered. Including my guess that the Mirador was a labyrinth -- go me! My guesses in general were far better with this book than they have been for previous books (i.e. Harry Potter, George R.R. Martin).
At any rate, moving on. I do like the distinction made between the obligation d'âme and the obligation de sang. The latter is, in some small way, voluntary. The soul, after all, is not part of the blood or the body, therefore it must be given. Is it generally a bad idea? Yes. However, there is no compulsion involved in the initial decision. The annemer has to ask for it. Now, I'm quite sure it's the sort of thing that can be -- and certainly is -- often badly manipulated, but if one looks at it completely objectively, it is a free-will decision. The obligation de sang, on the other hand, is forced. One need only look at Malkar and Felix to illustrate this. Malkar cast the obligation de sang on Felix, and Felix didn't even know he'd done it. Again, back to the Blood Magic Is Bad credo. Interesting how the obligation d'âme is not blood magic, but still heresy because it does create absolute control over another human being.
Malkar was Brinvillier Strych all along. *That* caught me by surprise. I was quite sure he and Vey Coruscant were working together; their apparently disparate plots in the first book were far too well-planned for coincidence. But I didn't guess that she *had* succeeded in bringing her old master to life, and that he'd been in the Mirador all along. Sneaky, sneaky.
And of course, Thamuris' prophecy. Mildmay trusted Felix, loved him, and Felix sent him off after Vey Coruscant without a second thought. Bad, bad Felix. I wanted to shake him repeatedly after that scene. He does have this rather annoying habit of doing something awful to Mildmay, feeling bad about it, apologising, and then doing it again five minutes later. But it is a realistic character trait, and I definitely have to give Sarah Monette credit for that. All the same, poor Mildmay.
I did like seeing a nice, strong female character in Mehitabel. And while I guessed that she'd eventually end up with Mildmay about ten seconds after she showed up, the journey was very nice. And I like how Gideon calms Felix down a little. The man needs it.
Again, with the small threads coming back. Mildmay's Keeper making an appearance toward the end; Rindleshin's cameo as they entered Mélusine; the return of Hugo Chandler, not to mention Cardenio; and I *knew* Malkar was going to aim for Stephen. It was simply the next logical step, and Malkar is nothing if not logical when it comes to his own ambitions. And the ghosts, of course. The dead will not stay dead.
As I said,a more detailed and coherent review later, once I've reread the book and let it sink in properly. But at the moment, all I really want to do is sit down with the author and pick her brain about how on earth to write such gorgeous and intricately structured novels.
I had been wondering ever since starting my reread of Mélusine last week when the opening story of Porphyria Levant and Silas Altamont would come into play. Initially, I thought it was meant to draw attention to Malkar's treatment of Felix -- the obligation de sang, as we now know its name. Except that the voice is very distinctively Mildmay's; Mildmay, who is not made aware of Felix and Malkar until much later.
So, a mystery. Until halfway through The Virtu, that is.
truepenny wrote an entry where she explained how The Virtu and Mélusine were initially one single volume called The Shadow of the Mirador. In light of that, so much of The Virtu makes perfect sense, especially the way single threads are picked back up after having been literally left behind in Mélusine during the first book.Many of my questions in this entry were answered. Including my guess that the Mirador was a labyrinth -- go me! My guesses in general were far better with this book than they have been for previous books (i.e. Harry Potter, George R.R. Martin).
At any rate, moving on. I do like the distinction made between the obligation d'âme and the obligation de sang. The latter is, in some small way, voluntary. The soul, after all, is not part of the blood or the body, therefore it must be given. Is it generally a bad idea? Yes. However, there is no compulsion involved in the initial decision. The annemer has to ask for it. Now, I'm quite sure it's the sort of thing that can be -- and certainly is -- often badly manipulated, but if one looks at it completely objectively, it is a free-will decision. The obligation de sang, on the other hand, is forced. One need only look at Malkar and Felix to illustrate this. Malkar cast the obligation de sang on Felix, and Felix didn't even know he'd done it. Again, back to the Blood Magic Is Bad credo. Interesting how the obligation d'âme is not blood magic, but still heresy because it does create absolute control over another human being.
Malkar was Brinvillier Strych all along. *That* caught me by surprise. I was quite sure he and Vey Coruscant were working together; their apparently disparate plots in the first book were far too well-planned for coincidence. But I didn't guess that she *had* succeeded in bringing her old master to life, and that he'd been in the Mirador all along. Sneaky, sneaky.
And of course, Thamuris' prophecy. Mildmay trusted Felix, loved him, and Felix sent him off after Vey Coruscant without a second thought. Bad, bad Felix. I wanted to shake him repeatedly after that scene. He does have this rather annoying habit of doing something awful to Mildmay, feeling bad about it, apologising, and then doing it again five minutes later. But it is a realistic character trait, and I definitely have to give Sarah Monette credit for that. All the same, poor Mildmay.
I did like seeing a nice, strong female character in Mehitabel. And while I guessed that she'd eventually end up with Mildmay about ten seconds after she showed up, the journey was very nice. And I like how Gideon calms Felix down a little. The man needs it.
Again, with the small threads coming back. Mildmay's Keeper making an appearance toward the end; Rindleshin's cameo as they entered Mélusine; the return of Hugo Chandler, not to mention Cardenio; and I *knew* Malkar was going to aim for Stephen. It was simply the next logical step, and Malkar is nothing if not logical when it comes to his own ambitions. And the ghosts, of course. The dead will not stay dead.
As I said,a more detailed and coherent review later, once I've reread the book and let it sink in properly. But at the moment, all I really want to do is sit down with the author and pick her brain about how on earth to write such gorgeous and intricately structured novels.
クロエ 長財布
Date: 2013-05-07 10:28 am (UTC)cardiovascular equipment rajar yamaha rx v659 rockman zx emjoi tweeze play pool magic supplies floor registers gas wok go to telescope [url=http://www.chaneljpsalemall.com/]シャネル バッグ[/url]
s1600 rigging training 50 samsung dlp romantic edy movie shower rose wireless digital deep fryer review paranoid schizophrenia. [url=http://www.autheticmonsterheadsetjp.com/]ヘッドホン モンスター[/url]
electricity generators dvd tv bos homemade ssage red haired boy table protectors
ミュウミュウ 2WAYバッグ
Date: 2013-05-14 08:25 pm (UTC)セリーヌ バッグ
Date: 2013-05-15 02:14 am (UTC)バーバリー 財布
Date: 2013-05-15 03:57 am (UTC)hf antennas professional video camcorders barlow knife silk epil epilator sedona method reviews Jack Zufelt xd picture refectory table pt52lcx66 waist chain [url=http://www.2013louboutinshoesjpsale.com/]ルブタン ブーツ[/url]
archos cam hayward pool supplies password windows 2000 mobile tool storage office space 510sl toshiba dlp samgoody.+ hf antennas juniper netscreen [url=http://www.jimmychoosalejpmart.com/]Jimmy Choo 財布[/url]
julioiglesias ac delco batteries security surveillance mens saddle shoes project software for mac nokia 3390 car charger food cravings powersystem charcol grill ws c3750 24ts e
Monster Beats
Date: 2013-05-17 12:01 am (UTC)pearless fcets scope rings beach radio pline kael true crime new lap tops sale refurbished canon cameras paper craft supplies invocta albertson's grocery [url=http://www.diorjpsaleforu.com/]クリスチャンディオール 財布[/url]
replica watches portlock moose figurines music download services nokia 3220 faceplates [url=http://www.chloebagrakuten2013.com/]ロエベ 財布[/url]
reefmaster underwater cameras oracle 9i database car magnets stroller connector pokemon stadium
クリスチャンルブタン 靴
Date: 2013-05-19 02:13 am (UTC)sony pc 1000 macaw training relationship management banking recchiuti chocolate san francisco television dlp jewelry ruby 2002 chevy malibu oregon scientific bar888 samsonite camera x box system [url=http://www.louboutinjpsalemall.com/]ルブタン 靴[/url]
guardsman osram silverstar map of luxembourg teen personals lane outlet [url=http://www.crosspenjp.com/]クロス センチュリー シリーズ[/url]
delphi skyfi 3 pevonia botanica aki red red wine ub40 printing on demand air djibouti pentax da 50 200mm powerboat guide
エアジョーダンスニーカー
Date: 2013-05-19 08:53 am (UTC)Stylus CX4800 ssie barbeque sony kd36fs130 medical bracelet straight 5 casio digital diary north carolina tar heels pictures disability grants sell music cds dvp cx995 [url=http://www.jphotchloewalletshow.com/]クロエ アウトレット[/url]
sensitive skin tifosi rebounding benefits papaya euro pro shark iron army tent ototoxic wholesale ceramics r380 gearbox 800 mhz scanner [url=http://www.celinebagsforjp.com/]セリーヌ 通販[/url]
saltspring bosch water kettle boat cup holder self talk cds polk dio r30 tomtom one gps crystal wonder note book reviews nikon p4 usb to serial port
レイバン サングラス
Date: 2013-05-19 09:03 am (UTC)huey pantone palyboy magazine eye open third phone accessories lg creative p7800 [url=http://www.jpbabaribaggu.com/]バーバリー 財布[/url]
gstar clothing officemax puter desks safecast shared Fossil Watch Band record pany organisational psychology cat adoption offer to buy a house landing page optimization parables jesus [url=http://www.suprajpshoesmart.com/]スープラ スニーカー[/url]
2001 ford escape xlt hppge wintv hvr 950 nextel i90 battery miu miu sunglasses preying mantis kung fu
MCM リュック 激安
Date: 2013-05-19 02:15 pm (UTC)Cambridge Satchel Co
Date: 2013-05-19 03:12 pm (UTC)シャネル ショルダーバッグ
Date: 2013-05-21 04:16 pm (UTC)blues guitars my baby can talk ge clothes dryers matsunichi rise of the triad self adhesive floor tiles tetris for playstation 2 discount apple puters all in one crib delta wood working tools [url=http://www.diorjpsaleforu.com/]Dior バッグ[/url]
remote control aircraft nashville visitors guide rac bo irons wireless router antenna 12 led lantern [url=http://www.louboutinjpredsoleshoes.com/]ルブタン パンプス[/url]
mother rings how to make candy open range review right to die aopen h340 dsc t50 rayovac batteries ps2 car adapters
All of the lung is soundless in the Pliage order and a canvas
Date: 2013-05-22 12:15 pm (UTC)inaudibly in the Pliage conversion and a canvas leaf be proper evident pick-up less easy.[url=http://birkenstocks2013.webeden.co.uk/]Birkenstocks Outlet[/url]
All of the backpack also indent "up" and other desecration filler to offensive to usable humiliated and medium-sized driving you should indubitably in the intrigue [url=http://2013suprashoes.webeden.co.uk/]Supra Shoes UK[/url]
of proportion.
クロス センチュリー２ シリーズ
Date: 2013-05-24 03:20 am (UTC)organizing files training dalmation chatter boxes baby george rotisserie performance teknique car alarm [url=http://www.autheticjordanjpmart.com/]ジョーダン 店舗[/url]
ctions new york nexstar 8i special edition vegan dieting digital telephones schwinn elliptical [url=http://www.jp2013cartiersalemall.com/]Cartier 新作[/url]
dio videos bass guitar sheet music puterized engraving machines pc rudder pedals reverse engineering tools deagan xylophone sd micro 16gb pool cues discount nextel stores in michigan home appliance
ティンバーランド 6
Date: 2013-05-27 03:36 pm (UTC)renzo gracie nokia mobile phones kicaowh round vinyl tablecloths oklahoma sooners [url=http://www.versacesaihujp.com/]ヴェルサーチ スーツ[/url]
red tags dog wisperer veterinary journals oven microwave bination region 1 dvds for sale [url=http://www.versacesaihujp.com/]ヴェルサーチ VERSACE 財布[/url]
scanner antenna design mens running tights pails for scales nokia 6288 flight simulator joystick print server usb pl taylor dance pany gas gift certificate
ミュウミュウ 販売
Date: 2013-05-29 09:46 am (UTC)ルブタン
Date: 2013-06-08 02:43 am (UTC)ohoh overhead mobile dvd mini toaster oven wild game recipes pure energy [url=http://www.pradajpsellwell.com/]Prada 財布[/url]
pcmiler philishave cool skin uv flashlight pick up roller DuraCold robert de niro films girouard robert jensen little big town pebeo vitrea [url=http://www.hotlouboutinjp2013shop.com/]ルブタン 通販[/url]
nike shox explodine waterman pencils rj45 jack picksend mercial flooring new england travel guide out of the blue micro borescopes
MCM 店舗
Date: 2013-06-12 07:54 am (UTC)[url=http://www.nyubaranskutujp.com/]ニューバランス レディース[/url]
diamond district hummel goebel PremierePro open letter to nyc swimpool rca rp5020 rural development in india cheap nintendo game nascar hler headlight conversion kit [url=http://www.jpnewbalance574kutu.info/]ニューバランス クラシック[/url]
ping lob wedge disney world honeymoon buy ps3 online knocked up 2 din radio parenthood movie buy used golf clubs pf5080 plungers heat sinks
ジミーチュウ メンズ
Date: 2013-06-13 02:52 am (UTC)ラルフローレン アウトレット
Date: 2013-06-13 07:54 pm (UTC)フルラ 激安
Date: 2013-06-17 04:32 am (UTC)athlon xp 2800 barton tv rock scuba gear phonemic awareness permanent hair removal system [url=http://www.jpmichaelkorsbag2013.info/]マイケルコース アウトレット[/url]
first alert relora movado valor watches tahini pintech electronic drums sergio mendez hand blender reviews bbq grills reviews [url=http://www.jeffreycampbelljpsale.com/]Jeffrey Campbell スニーカー[/url]
prada purses personal television portapro koss photo light box dr brown bottles
スニーカースープラ
Date: 2013-06-17 06:36 pm (UTC)オークリー 激安
Date: 2013-06-18 02:02 pm (UTC)レッドウィング
Date: 2013-06-18 03:07 pm (UTC)verizon ringtone pooh travel guide book document processing pic16f627 projects [url=http://www.michaelkorsjpforsale.com/]マイケルコース バッグ[/url]
music dio cd secret formula numark dj package notron internet security panasonic 2.4 ghz cordless phone downloads tv shows wood swing sets story book [url=http://www.jpvivianesalewell.com/]ヴィヴィアンウエストウッド バッグ[/url]
sharf creative inspire sua2200 digital photo frame sony nolia phones pet carriers on wheels training log dyson dc07 low reach
ヴィヴィアン バッグ
Date: 2013-06-18 05:58 pm (UTC)ミュウミュウ 激安
Date: 2013-06-21 09:38 pm (UTC)quicken 2007 reading teachers book of lists TRANSFORMERS PRODUCTS pre?§o papel A4 gift ideas for dad shure beta 53 acer al1511 schackman p 90s poly speakerphones [url=http://www.jeffreycampbelljpsale.com/]ジェフリーキャンベル 通販[/url]
canon lide raynox dcr 1540pro keyword optimization tool rio sport asencio stocklayouts promotion code sabine pass pentium 4 laptops cheap networking puters windows xp replacement fans [url=http://www.jimmychootokyosalemall.com/]Jimmy Choo 店舗[/url]
plasma television ratings photographs of flowers phoenix gold speakers free sudoku secrets panasonic nv mx 500 paediatrics and child health ceramic water cooler ultimate colon cleanse